While I agree that heat pumps do move heat from one location to another, I strongly disagree with the premise that air-source and geothermal heat pumps are not renewable energy heat sources. To support this position, I point to the ultimate source of low-temperature heat that is absorbed by the evaporator of these heat pumps. That source is the sun.
In the case of geothermal heat pumps, this solar energy is temporarily stored within the upper portion of the earth’s crust for a few weeks or months until it is needed by the load. This is especially true for systems with horizontal earth loops. Figure 1 shows how the undisturbed soil temperature at relatively shallow depths varies above and below an average value, based on depth and time of year.
It’s easy to see that deeper soils experience less variation in temperature. The solar heat gains of summer and cooling periods of winter simply have less effect at greater depths. It’s also evident there is a “phase shift” in the sinusoidal temperature curves based on depth. Deeper soils reach their maximum temperatures later in the year. For example, soils at 8-ft. depth reach their maximum temperature several weeks later than temperatures at the surface. This behavior is a direct result of solar heat gains combined with the thermal storage effect of soils.
Solar heat gain also is the ultimate source of heat for geothermal heat pumps with vertical earth loops. Even loops reaching 500 ft. into the earth are only penetrating about 0.4% into the earth’s crust (where its thickness is about 40 km). In most locations, very little heat from magma under the earth’s crust influences the heat being absorbed by the earth loop of a geothermal heat pump. The deeper the soil, the less the annual variation in temperature. What variation there is will be centered on the average annual air temperature at the location.
Few would argue that solar heat gain is responsible for the low-grade heat absorbed by air-source heat pumps. The more solar energy a given location gets, the warmer the average outdoor air temperature.
A reasonable comparison
The thermal performance of heat pumps, when operating in heating mode, is measured by an index called Coefficient Of Performance. It’s the ratio of the heat output from the heat pump divided by the energy input to operate the heat pump.
For a geothermal heat pump operating at a COP of 3.0, two units of heat are coming from the ground (e.g., free solar-sourced heat) and the remaining unit of heat is coming from electrical energy operating the compressor. Thus, two-thirds or 66.6% of the heat delivered to a building is, ultimately, from heat driven into the soil by the sun.
Now consider a solar thermal water-heating system, which just about everyone would consider a renewable energy system. Suppose this system supplies 66.6% of a home’s hot water needs from absorbed solar energy and the remaining 33.4% from the backup electric element, which may be supplied from a power plant the burns coal or natural gas. Again, two-thirds of the energy delivered for use came from the sun, and the remaining one-third came from electricity.
So, based on this comparison, both systems deliver the same ratio of useful effect divided by required electrical input. Why should the solar thermal system be labelled “renewable” and the geothermal heat pump system “nonrenewable”?
Heat pump semantics
The Internet posting also points out that terminology such as “geothermal” invokes images of heat derived from deep within the earth’s magma. True, locations do exist where geothermal heat comes to the surface, or close to the surface, as water or steam that was heated by magma. However, the term “geothermal heat pump” should provide some differentiation with geothermal heat derived from magma.
Still, the author of the posting does have a point that few people really understand this. After all, most of us took earth science at some point during high school. We learned about all this molten rock that the earth’s crust floats around on. As I recall, geothermal heat pumps were not mentioned in these earth science classes.
I was once taken to task by a fellow engineer for using the term geothermal heat pump. His point was that these devices should be called ground-source heat pumps. Technically, the “source” for a refrigeration cycle is always the low-temperature heat being absorbed and the “sink” is where the higher-temperature heat is dissipated. So, in heating mode, the earth is the source of heat and the term “ground source” certainly applies.
However, in cooling mode, the source is indoor air that’s being cooled and dehumidified. Thus, to be technically accurate, the same heat pump, operating in cooling mode, should be called a “ground-sink” heat pump.
The term “earth-coupled heat pump” avoids the ambiguity associated with both geothermal and ground source. It’s not specific to just one mode of operation. Still, just as the term boiler is still applied to many devices that don’t boil water, I don’t expect the term geothermal to disappear from our industry’s vocabulary anytime soon.
So, based on the ultimate source of the low-temperature heat, I do consider both earth-coupled and air-source heat pumps as renewable energy devices. Without the sun, there wouldn’t be much point of setting one of these systems up — or for me writing this column.
Both water-to-water and air-to-water heat pumps will play increasingly important roles within hydronic systems that heat and cool buildings. The electricity needed to operate them, while currently produced in large part by burning coal and gas, will slowly shift to being produced in greater proportions from sources such as solar photovoltaic systems, large-scale wind turbines, increased used of hydropower and even power plants that burn carbon-neutral biomass.
These sources position electricity as the universal high-grade energy source that will be used, albeit in very judicious and thermodynamically appropriate ways, to heat and cool buildings. Heat pumps will be the linkage between all that free solar-derived, low-temperature heat floating around, and beneath, us and the comfort humans require in their structures.
If you are selling heat pump systems, take time to explain to potential customers how they work and where the free heat ultimately comes from. They will feel good about it and better appreciate how important solar energy is.