This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • Home
  • Products
  • News
  • Glitch & Fix
  • Hydronics
  • Radiant
    • Radiant Comfort Report
  • Blogs/Columns
    • R&H On The Road
    • John Siegenthaler
    • Dan Holohan
    • Ray Wohlfarth
    • Mark Eatherton: Radiant Know-How
  • Buyers Guide
  • Resources
    • Radiant Comfort Report Digital
    • Rep Locator
    • Industry Calendar
    • Store
    • Market Research
    • eNewsletters
  • Plumbing & Mechanical
Home » Modified primary/secondary hydronic piping system
Hydronic TechnologyThe Glitch & The FixRadiant & Hydronics

Modified primary/secondary hydronic piping system

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Glitch drawing

Glitch drawing: An installer wants to achieve hydraulic separation between three zone circulators. He also wants to have the same supply water temperature to each zone, so he pipes up what he calls a “modified primary/secondary system,” as shown in the drawing above. Graphics credit: John Siegenthaler, P.E.

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 1

Fix drawing 1: Assume the first zone circulator was operational at a flow rate of 10 gal. per min., the second zone circulator was off and the third zone circulator was operating at 4 gpm. Also assume that the flow rate created by the primary circulator was 15 gpm. Graphics credit: John Siegenthaler, P.E.

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 2

Fix drawing 2: Keep all three zone flow rates the same, but reduce the primary flow rate from 15 gpm to 8 gpm. The result is shown above. Graphics credit: John Siegenthaler, P.E.

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 3

Fix drawing 3: The bottom line is that you can’t rely on the piping arrangement to produce acceptable results in all cases — unless you blast water around the primary loop at high flows. A simple solution is to install a hydraulic separator between the boiler and distribution circuits, as shown above. Graphics credit: John Siegenthaler, P.E.

March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Glitch drawing
March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 1
March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 2
March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix -- Fix drawing 3
March 18, 2016
John Siegenthaler, P.E.
KEYWORDS hydronic controls / hydronic system design / incorrect design / schematic layout
Reprints
No Comments

The Glitch

An installer wants to achieve hydraulic separation between three zone circulators. He also wants to have the same supply water temperature to each zone. He pipes up what he calls a “modified primary/secondary system,” as shown in the Glitch drawing above. His rationale is that since all the zone returns are downstream of the zone supplies, each supply will have the same supply water temperature.

Can you think of a situation where this will work? How about where it will not work?

The Fix

Each zone will get the same supply water temperature if and only if the flow rate created by the primary circulator is greater than the total of all the active zone flow rates.

For example, assume the first zone circulator was operational at a flow rate of 10 gal. per min., the second zone circulator was off and the third zone circulator was operating at 4 gpm. Also assume that the flow rate created by the primary circulator was 15 gpm. This would produce the result shown in the Fix 1 drawing above. All zones would be receiving water at the same temperature.

Now, keep all three zone flow rates the same, but reduce the primary flow rate from 15 gpm to 8 gpm. The result is shown in Fix 2 drawing above.

Notice that the flow between the third and fourth tee has reversed. This is the only possible scenario since the flow entering any portion of the system has to be the same as the flow leaving that portion of the system.

The water “doesn’t care” that it is flowing backwards, but you should. That’s because there will be no heated water entering zone No. 3, and the flow sent into zone No. 1 will be mixed (eight parts heated water with two parts return water). This will obviously have detrimental effects on the heat delivery of these zones.

There are many other possibilities for what might happen based on assumptions for the primary loop flow rate and the combined zone flow rates. The bottom line is that you can’t rely on this piping arrangement to produce acceptable results in all cases — unless you blast water around the primary loop at high flows (e.g., always keeping the primary flow rate greater than what the total zone flow rates might be).

The latter is possible but it’s also wasteful. It requires larger circulators and larger piping, and could result in hundreds of dollars’ worth of unnecessary pumping energy use over the life of the system.
There are several ways to correct this situation. One of the simplest is to install a hydraulic separator between the boiler and distribution circuits, as shown in the Fix 3 drawing.

This arrangement ensures equal supply water temperature to all zones under all circumstances. The hydraulic separator also replaces the high-performance air separator and provides dirt separation for the system.

Keep in mind that the boiler circuit flow rate does not have to equal or exceed the total zone flow rate. My suggestion is to select a boiler flow rate that’s relatively wide —perhaps 30° F or more, provided that the boiler is compatible with that flow rate and the return water temperature to the boiler stays above the dew point of the flue gases. A boiler inlet temperature of 130° is generally sufficient for the latter.

Download a pdf of the March 2016 The Glitch and The Fix.

This originally appeared as "'Modified' primary/secondary" in the March 2016 issue of Plumbing & Mechanical.

pm-subscribe

Recent Articles by John Siegenthaler, P.E.

John Siegenthaler: New in the neighborhood

The Glitch and Fix: Keep the cost down

Single coil solution

John Siegenthaler: Low temperature leverage

John Siegenthaler: Expansion etiquette

Siegenthaler

John Siegenthaler, P.E., is a consulting engineer and principal of Appropriate Designs in Holland Patent, N.Y. His latest textbook “Heating With Renewable Energy,” will be released in January 2016 from Cengage Publishing. It shows how to use modern hydronics technology to create systems supplied by solar thermal, heat pump and biomass heat sources. Additional information is available at www.hydronicpros.com.

Related Articles

Primary/secondary/ thirdinary

Primary/secondary systems need proper detailing to work correctly

Primary Or Secondary?

A primary concern in a multiboiler system

You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

RCR logo

RCR Buyers Guide

Plumbing and Mechanical

Plumbing & Mechanical December 2019

2019 December

Check out the December 2019 edition of Plumbing & Mechanical: 2020 B.I.G. Book, John Siegenthaler on geothermal water-to-water heat pump system design and installation, maximizing efficiency on small-diameter piping projects and much more!
View More Create Account
  • Resources
    • Reprints
    • List Rental
    • Contact Us
    • AEC Store
    • Blogs
    • Radiant & Hydronics
    • Industry Links
    • Market Research
    • Custom Content & Marketing Services
    • Privacy Policy
  • Want More
    • Connect
    • Survey And Sample
  • Plumbing Group
    • PM Engineer
    • Supply House Times
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Plan for 2020!

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing