• Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
  • CONTRACTORS
  • ENGINEERS
  • RADIANT & HYDRONICS
  • INSIGHTS
  • MEDIA
  • RESOURCES
  • EMAGAZINE
  • SIGN UP!
cart
facebook instagram twitter linkedin youtube
  • CONTRACTORS
  • BATH & KITCHEN PRO
  • BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
  • HIGH EFFICIENCY HOMES
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • WATER TREATMENT
  • PMC COLUMNS
  • PMC COLUMNS
  • Dave Yates: Contractor’s Corner
  • John Siegenthaler: Hydronics Workshop
  • Kenny Chapman: The Blue Collar Coach
  • Matt Michel: Service Plumbing Pros
  • Scott Secor: Heating Perceptions
  • ENGINEERS
  • CONTINUING EDUCATION
  • DECARBONIZATION | ELECTRIFICATION
  • FIRE PROTECTION
  • GEOTHERMAL | SOLAR THERMAL
  • PIPING | PLUMBING | PVF
  • PME COLUMNS
  • PME COLUMNS
  • Christoph Lohr: Strategic Plumbing Insights
  • David Dexter: Plumbing Talking Points
  • James Dipping: Engineer Viewpoints
  • John Seigenthaler: Renewable Heating Design
  • Lowell Manalo: Plumbing Essentials
  • Misty Guard: Guard on Compliance
  • RADIANT & HYDRONICS
  • RADIANT COMFORT REPORT
  • THE GLITCH & THE FIX
  • INSIGHTS
  • CODES
  • GREEN PLUMBING & MECHANICAL
  • PROJECT PROFILES
  • COLUMNS
  • SPONSOR INSIGHTS
  • COLUMNS
  • Codes Corner
  • Natalie Forster: Editorial Opinion
  • Guest Editorial
  • MEDIA
  • PODCASTS
  • VIDEOS
  • WEBINARS
  • RESOURCES
  • INDUSTRY CALENDAR
  • DIRECTORIES
  • EBOOKS
  • PM BOOKSTORE
  • CE CENTER
  • MARKET RESEARCH
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EMAGAZINE
  • EMAGAZINE
  • ARCHIVE ISSUES
  • CONTACT
  • ADVERTISE
  • PME EMAGAZINE ARCHIVES
search
cart
facebook instagram twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
  • CONTRACTORS
    • BATH & KITCHEN PRO
    • BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
    • HIGH EFFICIENCY HOMES
    • TECHNOLOGY
    • WATER TREATMENT
    • PMC COLUMNS
      • Dave Yates: Contractor’s Corner
      • John Siegenthaler: Hydronics Workshop
      • Kenny Chapman: The Blue Collar Coach
      • Matt Michel: Service Plumbing Pros
      • Scott Secor: Heating Perceptions
  • ENGINEERS
    • CONTINUING EDUCATION
    • DECARBONIZATION | ELECTRIFICATION
    • FIRE PROTECTION
    • GEOTHERMAL | SOLAR THERMAL
    • PIPING | PLUMBING | PVF
    • PME COLUMNS
      • Christoph Lohr: Strategic Plumbing Insights
      • David Dexter: Plumbing Talking Points
      • James Dipping: Engineer Viewpoints
      • John Seigenthaler: Renewable Heating Design
      • Lowell Manalo: Plumbing Essentials
      • Misty Guard: Guard on Compliance
  • RADIANT & HYDRONICS
    • RADIANT COMFORT REPORT
    • THE GLITCH & THE FIX
  • INSIGHTS
    • CODES
    • GREEN PLUMBING & MECHANICAL
    • PROJECT PROFILES
    • COLUMNS
      • Codes Corner
      • Natalie Forster: Editorial Opinion
      • Guest Editorial
    • SPONSOR INSIGHTS
  • MEDIA
    • PODCASTS
    • VIDEOS
    • WEBINARS
  • RESOURCES
    • INDUSTRY CALENDAR
    • DIRECTORIES
    • EBOOKS
    • PM BOOKSTORE
    • CE CENTER
    • MARKET RESEARCH
    • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EMAGAZINE
    • EMAGAZINE
    • ARCHIVE ISSUES
    • CONTACT
    • ADVERTISE
    • PME EMAGAZINE ARCHIVES
  • SIGN UP!
Columns

Full Circle

By John Siegenthaler, P.E.
May 1, 2008
Will low head loss boilers make a come back?

Some of you have probably been installing hydronic heating for 30 years or more. Consider yourselves lucky to have witnessed not only a rebirth of the industry in North America, but also a steady refinement of technology.

I think it’s safe to say that no one who falls into this vintage is currently installing systems the same as they did 30 years ago. During the last three decades, there's been a deluge of new hardware for almost every aspect of the system from which to choose. Design concepts and objectives have also changed over this time.

The changes we’ve made and continue to make in system design are influenced by complex interactions - the people and companies we know, favorite technical concepts, cost-saving opportunities, energy-saving opportunities, what we read in trade magazines, and what we observe others doing. This holds true at all levels of the industry, from installer right up through the manufacturer.

Thinking that we’ll someday arrive at the ultimate design concept and hardware configuration implies limits that few of us would be willing to accept. Although what you might be doing today is “state-of-the-art,” it will surely loose that title, perhaps even by next year.

Without this continuous movement, our industry would eventually cease to exist, especially as competing technologies constantly offer up a challenge. If you don’t believe this, do some research on the state of hydronic radiant panel heating in North America a mere 30 years ago. If PEX tubing hadn’t shown up to breathe new life into the concept, it was all but dead.

Sometimes our industry goes down technological paths that later prove less than optimal. Of course, no one realizes this until looking back. Sometimes we also find that old concepts aren’t necessarily dead, even though they’ve been mothballed for a while as other “contemporary” approaches enjoy their time in the spotlight.

This month I want to look at a situation in which a technical detail our industry relied on extensively 30 years ago, one that some might consider “over the hill” as evidenced by today’s standard practice, has the potential to re-emerge and move the industry forward in the process.

A state-of-the-art hydronic heating system circa 1978 was usually built around a cast-iron or steel boiler connected to a masonry chimney. A site-built black iron header came off the top or side of that boiler. The tees it contained ran off to two, or maybe in a big house, three zones of series-connected finned-tube baseboard. Those zones returned to a corresponding number of zone valves mounted on the return header. The header connected to a three-piece circulator, and then to the boiler’s return connection. On the side or front of the boiler was a tankless coil for domestic water heating.

One of the nice features of this system - though not fully appreciated at the time - was the low-flow resistance of the boiler and header piping. This characteristic allowed multiple zones to operate essentially as if they were stand-alone circuits. When a given circuit turned on or off, there was minimal affect on other circuits. Things were pretty simple.

Figure 1

Smaller Body, Bigger Head

The push for increased energy efficiency brought with it some radical new ideas about boiler design. A trend developed toward low-mass condensing boilers with heat exchangers made of finned copper tubing or stainless steel.

This combination certainly reduced the size and weight of boilers, as well as their warm-up time. In most cases, it also introduced a very different flow characteristic to the boiler, that of high head loss relative to traditional boilers.

One early example was the GlowCore boiler, which had a coiled copper heat exchanger surrounding a cylindrical burner. The pressure drop of the tightly coiled heat exchanger was much greater than that of other boilers being installed at the time.

Many installers overlooked the consequences of this characteristic and installed the GlowCore boiler just like a cast-iron boiler, with all system flow piped through the boiler. This often bottlenecked the system, leading to inadequate heat delivery. The opposite situation also occurred when zone valves were used. Flow starvation through the boiler’s low-mass heat exchanger under low load conditions lead to damaged heat exchangers.

Some of you probably remember the reputation that GlowCore boilers eventually got. A reputation that in hind site was largely the result of improper application and failure to recognize that the industry had reached the point where not all boilers could be piped the same.

Eventually the industry learned to connect compact condensing boilers into the system as a secondary circuit with its own dedicated circulator. Today this is a common detail in installation schematics for such boilers. This realization even led to the development and use of new devices such as hydraulic separators.

Are We There Yet?

Adding a separate circulator, in some cases a high head circulator, solves the issue of providing adequate boiler flow regardless of what’s happening in the distribution system. At the same time, it also adds to both installation and operating cost relative to the older systems, where all flow passed through the boiler.

In some cases, the hydraulic separation of a boiler from the distribution system also creates a deviation between boiler outlet temperature and the temperature of water supplied to the distribution system as shown in Figure 1.

Some boiler operating controls use an externally mounted sensor to measure the temperature of water supplied to the distribution system; others do not. Those that don’t are often set to produce an outlet temperature slightly higher than that needed by the distribution system. This is done in an attempt to keep supply temperature close to what’s needed after the flows have mixed at the point of hydraulic separation. This also means the boiler operates at a temperature higher than necessary and thus at a slightly reduced efficiency.

There are only two ways that I’m aware of to ensure that boiler modulation is controlled based on the supply temperature to the distribution system:

  • Measure this temperature and modulate the burner based on it (e.g., using a system supply temperature sensor mounted downstream of the point of hydraulic separation).

  • Pass all system flow through boiler and eliminate the hydraulic separation point and its associated mixing.

    Either of these approaches is viable, but the option of passing all flow through the mod/con boiler offers the added benefit of eliminating the boiler circulator, its associated piping, and the life-cycle operating cost of this circulator.

    One might argue that the electrical energy consumption associated with pushing flow through a boiler will occur regardless of whether that power is fed into a separate boiler circulator or through the system circulator. This is not necessarily true.

    Although the mechanical power to push flow through the boiler at a given flow rate and associated pressure drop is the same, the corresponding electrical power required depends on the wire-to-water efficiency of the circulator supplying the mechanical power. The higher this efficiency, the lower the electrical power requirement. Thus, if the system circulator can operate at a higher wire-to-water efficiency than that of a small wet-rotor boiler circulator, it provides a slight advantage.

    This scenario is poised to become more common as ECM-based circulators, with wire-to-water efficiencies about double those of current PSC-based wet-rotor circulators, are increasingly used in hydronic distribution systems.

    Here’s an example of the potential savings for a small residential system:

    Assume a boiler has a head loss of 4 feet (pressure drop = 1.708 psi) at a corresponding flow rate of 20 gpm. The estimated electrical power to provide this condition using a small wet-rotor circulator with PSC motor and 22 percent wire-to-water efficiency is:


  • If this same mechanical energy were supplied from an ECM-based distribution circulator operating at 40 percent wire-to-water efficiency, the electrical wattage drops to:

    Assuming the boiler operates 3,000 hours per year and that electricity costs 10 cents per kwhr, the first-year savings would be as follows (based on the difference in operating wattage):

    Over 20 years, with electricity inflating at 4 percent per year, this works out to a savings of:

    Keep in mind that this is in addition to the cost savings from not installing a separate boiler circulator and associated piping. This would easily add up to $400 or more in additional savings in a small residential system.

    There are some mod/con boilers available in North America  capable of “pump through” application. The key is minimizing head loss through the boiler.

    Although there is no threshold that determines a go/no go decision for pumping through application, I suggest that the boiler should develop a loss no greater than 4 feet of head while passing full design flow rate through its heat exchanger. It’s also beneficial if the boiler’s heat exchanger can operate with a temperature rise of perhaps 30 degrees F or more under design load. Higher delta T means lower flow rates, lower head loss and, for a given supply temperature, lower return temperatures. The latter enhances flue gas condensation and boosts efficiency.

    Will the future of mod/con boilers be “pump through” design?  Will we eventually come back to systems as simple as a single-system pump (ECM-based variable speed) pushing flow through the boiler and then on to a distribution system zoned using zone valves or TRVs? Such an approach surely offers simplicity. It also reduces both installation and operating cost, as well as eliminates temperature variation between the boiler outlet and system supply. These characteristics are beneficial to both the customer and the installer.

    Links

    • Radiant & Hydronics e-News

    Share This Story

    Looking for a reprint of this article?
    From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

    Siegenthaler

    John Siegenthaler, P.E., is a consulting engineer and principal of Appropriate Designs in Holland Patent, New York. In partnership with HeatSpring, he has developed several online courses that provide in-depth, design-level training in modern hydronics systems, air-to-water heat pumps and biomass boiler systems. Additional information and resources for hydronic system design are available on Siegenthaler’s website,  www.hydronicpros.com.

    Recommended Content

    JOIN TODAY
    to unlock your recommendations.

    Already have an account? Sign In

    • Worker using the Milwaukee Tool SWITCH PACK drain cleaner

      Pipeline profits: Drain cleaning, pipe inspection create opportunities

      Drain cleaning and inspection services offer lucrative...
      Plumbing News
      By: Nicole Krawcke
    • Uponor employee, Arturo Moreno

      The reinvestment in American manufacturing and training

      Plumbing & Mechanical Chief Editor Nicole Krawcke and...
      Plumbing News
      By: Nicole Krawcke and Natalie Forster
    • March 2024 Women in Plumbing hero image of woman engineer overlayed by circle of hexagon shapes with numbers from 1 to 10

      Celebrating 10 Influential Women in the Plumbing Industry

      Celebrating Women's History Month and Women in...
      Plumbing News
      By: Nicole Krawcke
    Subscribe For Free!
    • eNewsletters
    • Online Registration
    • Subscription Customer Service
    • eMagazine
    • Manage My Preferences

    NIBCO Press Solutions

    NIBCO Press Solutions

    IPEX celebrates grand opening of new Florida distribution center

    IPEX celebrates grand opening of new Florida distribution center

    AI can boost efficiency and profitability for plumbing, HVAC contractors

    AI can boost efficiency and profitability for plumbing, HVAC contractors

    Bell & Gossett Illustrates Path to Net-zero at AHR Expo

    Bell & Gossett Illustrates Path to Net-zero at AHR Expo

    More Videos

    Sponsored Content

    Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Plumbing & Mechanical audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Plumbing & Mechanical or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

    close
    • J.J. Keller CMV vehicles on road
      Sponsored byJ. J. Keller & Associates, Inc.

      The dash cam game-changer for small business safety

    Popular Stories

    The interior of a government building.

    President Trump signs executive order promoting skilled trades and apprenticeships

    Figure 1 is a sketch of the flow problems of the current plumbing system.

    Hydronic heating glitch solved: Why adding a circulator won't fix primary loop flow issue

    Underfloor heating installation with drain sewer hole in bathroom close up on water floor heating.

    Using hydronics to leverage time-of-use electrical rates

    PM BEMIS June 25 Free Webinar: Optimizing Plumbing Solutions for Single-Family, Multi-Family & Public Spaces

    Events

    November 13, 2024

    Future Proofing MEP: Navigating the 2026 High Efficiency Water Heating Standards

    Join our deep dive into DOE’s new standards so you can future-proof your MEP practice.

    EARN: 0.1 ASPE CEU; 1 AIA LU/HSW; 0.1 IACET CEU*; 1 PDH

    View All Submit An Event

    Poll

    Will business be up or down in 2025?

    Do you anticipate business in 2025 to be up or down in comparison to 2024?
    View Results Poll Archive

    Products

    The Water Came To A Stop

    The Water Came To A Stop

    See More Products

    Download the FREE Water Conservation, Quality & Safety eBook: Plumbing Trends Increasing Safe Water Availability

    Related Articles

    • Siegenthaler PM

      John Siegenthaler: Designing cordwood gasification boiler

      See More
    • John Siegenthaler: Renewable Heating Design

      Flow rate, heat output and Delta-T

      See More
    • John Siegenthaler: Renewable Heating Design

      Multiple Boiler Systems

      See More
    ×

    Keep your content unclogged with our newsletters!

    Stay in the know on the latest plumbing & piping industry trends.

    JOIN TODAY!
    • RESOURCES
      • Advertise
      • Contact Us
      • Directories
      • Store
      • Want More
      • Supply House Times
    • SIGN UP TODAY
      • Create Account
      • eMagazine
      • eNewsletter
      • Customer Service
      • Manage Preferences
    • SERVICES
      • Marketing Services
      • Reprints
      • Market Research
      • List Rental
      • Survey/Respondent Access
    • STAY CONNECTED
      • LinkedIn
      • Facebook
      • Instagram
      • YouTube
      • X (Twitter)
    • PRIVACY
      • PRIVACY POLICY
      • TERMS & CONDITIONS
      • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
      • PRIVACY REQUEST
      • ACCESSIBILITY

    Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing

    search
    cart
    facebook instagram twitter linkedin youtube
    • Sign In
    • Create Account
    • Sign Out
    • My Account
    • NEWS
    • PRODUCTS
    • CONTRACTORS
      • BATH & KITCHEN PRO
      • BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
      • HIGH EFFICIENCY HOMES
      • TECHNOLOGY
      • WATER TREATMENT
      • PMC COLUMNS
        • Dave Yates: Contractor’s Corner
        • John Siegenthaler: Hydronics Workshop
        • Kenny Chapman: The Blue Collar Coach
        • Matt Michel: Service Plumbing Pros
        • Scott Secor: Heating Perceptions
    • ENGINEERS
      • CONTINUING EDUCATION
      • DECARBONIZATION | ELECTRIFICATION
      • FIRE PROTECTION
      • GEOTHERMAL | SOLAR THERMAL
      • PIPING | PLUMBING | PVF
      • PME COLUMNS
        • Christoph Lohr: Strategic Plumbing Insights
        • David Dexter: Plumbing Talking Points
        • James Dipping: Engineer Viewpoints
        • John Seigenthaler: Renewable Heating Design
        • Lowell Manalo: Plumbing Essentials
        • Misty Guard: Guard on Compliance
    • RADIANT & HYDRONICS
      • RADIANT COMFORT REPORT
      • THE GLITCH & THE FIX
    • INSIGHTS
      • CODES
      • GREEN PLUMBING & MECHANICAL
      • PROJECT PROFILES
      • COLUMNS
        • Codes Corner
        • Natalie Forster: Editorial Opinion
        • Guest Editorial
      • SPONSOR INSIGHTS
    • MEDIA
      • PODCASTS
      • VIDEOS
      • WEBINARS
    • RESOURCES
      • INDUSTRY CALENDAR
      • DIRECTORIES
      • EBOOKS
      • PM BOOKSTORE
      • CE CENTER
      • MARKET RESEARCH
      • CLASSIFIEDS
    • EMAGAZINE
      • EMAGAZINE
      • ARCHIVE ISSUES
      • CONTACT
      • ADVERTISE
      • PME EMAGAZINE ARCHIVES
    • SIGN UP!