Is There Anything Radiant Can't Do?
When everything's said and done, radiant tubing is basically a low mass heat emitter. And that basic job description is what accounts for installations that almost defy description.
About the only reality that holds radiant creativity back is the cost. Everything else is fair game.
We've reported on unusual installations before and heard about even more. According to the Radiant Panel Association, 192 million linear feet of radiant tubing was produced by North American suppliers in 2001. The RPA will report on the 2002 tally at this month's convention.
Let's look at a few cases in which some of this tubing went into some places you'd least expect, but most want:
The Beach BarThe trendy W Hotel group's San Diego operation has an interesting place to stop in for a drink. The Beach Bar is quite literally that -- a 2,000-sq. ft. open-air lounge with a foot of radiantly heated sand to sink your toes into.
Here are a few of the design highlights supplied to us by Jim Bishop, senior project manager for mechanical contractor, Critchfield Mechanical, Menlo Park, Calif.
To achieve this temperate temperature on top, the system was designed to run at temperatures of 100 degree from the bottom of the heated slab. "The temperature increased about 2 degrees for every inch of depth in an area where the sand thickness was 12 inches," Bishop says.
In addition to the sand "floor," the space also includes a radiantly heated bench that wraps around the perimeter of the lounge.
Naturally, the heated sand drew lots of attention with club hoppers standing in line on Friday and Saturday nights for a space that can hold less that 200 patrons. The hotel reportedly went through three months worth of booze in just the first month after opening the Sand Bar.
In fact, hotel owners were so impressed by the system that they wondered if the temperature of the sand could be made hotter.
The simple answer was no, with the complexities of why having to do more with the radiant ability of sand than the mechanical system. "Hot sand that we have all experienced on a bright sunny day is not possible in this case," Bishop says. "That sand is heated from the sun above. We are heating from below."
After examining the request, Bishop told owners that any temperature higher than 85 degrees F would be uncomfortable. Besides, a large increase in supply temperature would increase the sand surface temperature by only about 2 degrees. Although the surface temperature would only go up a little, the temperature at the top of the slab, and in the first inch or two of sand, would increase substantially.
"Even if the sand on the surface could be made to be hot to the touch, the sand just a few inches below the surface would most certainly be a burn hazard," Bishop says.
The 'Light'houseWhen homeowner Alan Haar decided to build atop a lakeside mountain, he wanted a home with expansive views of the countryside and interior spaces with few dividing walls. He also wanted to see the lake.
The surrounding forest, however, prevented unobstructed views of the lake.
"There was only one way to do it," he says. "Over the top."
The design he settled on was influenced by his long fascination with old lighthouses. Built like an octagonal wedding cake with each successive layer in smaller size, the home's top floor would feature 360-degree, eight-sided walls of glass with a view over a canopy of trees. Inside, an intricate framework of exposed beams would support the structure's mass with few interior walls.
But installing the mechanical systems presented new challenges. With so many exposed walls and ceilings, how would they facilitate heating, air conditioning and plumbing?
"Timber framed structures, by their design, challenge the proper installation of mechanical systems," says Tony Zaya, Lancaster County Timber Frames, Lancaster, Pa., an architect specializing in timber frame homes.
Already limited for concealing the heating, plumbing and drainage pipes, Zaya's design challenge was multiplied by the central opening up through each successively smaller floor.
The ground floor concrete slab was tubed with home runs to the main manifold for zoning flexibility between bed and bath groups. The upper hardwood floors cried out for radiant heating. But the 6-inch truss joist space was too narrow to house the PEX plumbing system, the electrical wiring, hi-velocity A/C ductwork and a plated under-floor radiant application.
Zaya solved the problem by using a "dry system," a specially manufactured subfloor various manufacturers make that provides more flexibility for contractors to install radiant tubing.
Given the octagonal construction and soon-to-be-installed pie-shaped wedges of hardwood flooring, Zaya needed a product with this type of space-saving design flexibility for diverting tubing runs around the massive timbers and where each of the eight floor sections abut the other.
Hot WaxRadiant tubing can do much more than just provide a room with warmth. That cozy comfort can also improve on commerce.
A few years ago, for example, we saw pictures of a 500-foot-long radiantly heated casting slab, used to cure concrete walls to deaden the sound between noisy freeways and residential areas.
The foot-thick walls are poured out on slab, located outside in the Arizona desert. Before radiant, the company would rely on the sun to cure their walls. But sunshine took three days; combined sun and radiant brought the wait time down to just one day.
We've also seen pictures of a honey processing plant in Pennsylvania, in which radiant kept the honey in a warm, easy-to-pour state without the worry of easily scorching the sugar.
What works for honey also applies to wax. For Every Body, a Lindon, Utah, manufacturer of candles, was looking to construct an assembly line to speed production to meet demand. The process called for transporting raw, molten wax from three storage tanks via stainless steel piping to five mixing tanks, where the material was colored and scented.
"They were selling candles faster than they could make them so they wanted to build a complete assembly line to speed production," says Dave Told, Told Plumbing, Pleasant Grove, Utah. "Heating the tanks seemed easy enough, but it was keeping wax hot while it traveled between the tanks."
Otherwise, one really big candle.
Told first considered wrapping all the pipe with Wirsbo PEX and then insulating it. In the end, however, it worked better to pair PEX and modified heat emission plates, then spacing them evenly around the stainless steel piping. Afterward, all the pipe also was insulated.
A Weil-McLain PGF 8 boiler maintains a temperature of 200 degrees F in its 3-inch primary loop that is in continuous circulation. The three large storage tanks that hold the wax are each equipped with a zone pump, controlled by a tekmar 150 set point control that uses four 071 sensors, placed in various locations within the tanks, to monitor the temperature of the wax.
"When there is a call for heat for the tanks, the zone pump pulls it out from the main loop," Told explains. Heating for the radiant tubing is also pulled off this using another zone pump. Since the loops supplying the piping vary dramatically in length, a flow-control manifold simplifies the balancing act.
According to the manufacturer, the plant can go from a "cold start" -- with all the wax in the tank and piping completely solidified -- to complete liquefaction in one to two hours.
Animal House(s)No doubt radiant heat provides creature comfort for humans, but how about creature comfort for other creatures?
Although rooftop HVAC provides the primary source of heat for the 7,800-sq. ft. Elephant House at the Indianapolis Zoo, Indianapolis, Ind., radiant was still installed to dry the floor quickly, prevented animals from slipping; and keep the animals feet warm.
The Wirsbo PEX system, fed by a 200,000-Btu Viessmann boiler, has different zones, allowing some areas to be kept warmer than others for, say, newborns. In this case, the most unusual aspect is the location of the manifolds. Rather than positioned in a wall, the manifolds are actually buried in the slabs in specially designed boxes.
"Elephants like to stand on their hind legs," says Brain Emmons, ????. "With their trunks in the air, their reach is enormous. With the manifolds buried in the slab, there's no way they can do any damage."
If radiant makes sense for warm-blooded animals, then it's that much better for cold-blooded reptiles.
Wirsbo also donated the tubing for an exhibit housing two Komodo dragons at the Minnesota Zoo. The space was designed to provide the lizards from Indonesia with temperatures of 80 to 100 degrees F. In order to keep the animals moving, the space includes six zones, including three floor zones and three "basking rock" zones.