search
cart
facebook instagram twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
  • CONTRACTORS
    • BATH & KITCHEN PRO
    • BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
    • HIGH EFFICIENCY HOMES
    • TECHNOLOGY
    • WATER TREATMENT
    • PMC COLUMNS
      • Dave Yates: Contractor’s Corner
      • John Siegenthaler: Hydronics Workshop
      • Kenny Chapman: The Blue Collar Coach
      • Matt Michel: Service Plumbing Pros
      • Scott Secor: Heating Perceptions
  • ENGINEERS
    • CONTINUING EDUCATION
    • DECARBONIZATION | ELECTRIFICATION
    • FIRE PROTECTION
    • GEOTHERMAL | SOLAR THERMAL
    • PIPING | PLUMBING | PVF
    • PME COLUMNS
      • Christoph Lohr: Strategic Plumbing Insights
      • David Dexter: Plumbing Talking Points
      • James Dipping: Engineer Viewpoints
      • John Seigenthaler: Renewable Heating Design
      • Lowell Manalo: Plumbing Essentials
      • Misty Guard: Guard on Compliance
  • RADIANT & HYDRONICS
    • RADIANT COMFORT REPORT
    • THE GLITCH & THE FIX
  • INSIGHTS
    • CODES
    • GREEN PLUMBING & MECHANICAL
    • PROJECT PROFILES
    • COLUMNS
      • Codes Corner
      • Natalie Forster: Editorial Opinion
      • Guest Editorial
    • SPONSOR INSIGHTS
  • MEDIA
    • PODCASTS
    • VIDEOS
    • WEBINARS
  • RESOURCES
    • INDUSTRY CALENDAR
    • DIRECTORIES
    • EBOOKS
    • PM BOOKSTORE
    • CE CENTER
    • MARKET RESEARCH
    • CLASSIFIEDS
  • EMAGAZINE
    • EMAGAZINE
    • ARCHIVE ISSUES
    • CONTACT
    • ADVERTISE
    • PME EMAGAZINE ARCHIVES
  • SIGN UP!
Columns

Harvey's Horseshoe

By John Siegenthaler, P.E.
December 1, 2005
Figure 1
If you attended the RPA RadFest East this past October, you may remember the piping schematic in Figure 1 as an example of what not to do.

The problem here is the lack of a thermal trap. True, you do see a trap in the plumbing sense. The injection riser piping does drop at least 18 inches below the primary loop before making the U-turn. But this piping geometry doesn't constitute a thermal trap. The reason is that the closely spaced tees that connect the injection risers to the primary loop are not at least 18 inches higher than the tees that connect to the distribution circuit.

Figure 2
Figure 2 shows the situation inside the trap when the injection pump shuts off after having shuttled heat to the distribution system.

The “U-tube” shape of the injection risers below the dashed line in Figure 2 is “buoyancy-balanced.” They do not create any unbalanced forces that would lead to buoyancy-induced heat migration. This is true for both the hot and cool U-tubes, even though the weight of hot water is less than that of cool water. It remains true regardless of how deep the U-shaped piping assembly is built.

Unfortunately, the injection risers above the dashed line are not buoyancy-balanced. Although the hot injection riser contains the same volume of water as the cool injection riser, the density of hot and cool water are not the same. This means the weight of water in the hot riser is less than that of the cool water in the cool riser.

Just like adding a slight extra weight to one side of an otherwise balanced seesaw causes it to rotate, the unbalanced buoyancy forces tend to keep the injection flow moving after the injection pump turns off. As long as hot water continues to flow through the primary loop (i.e., to supply other secondary circuits), this situation will persist. The slow thermosyphon effect continually “refuels” itself with hot water from the primary loop. The result will be heat migration into the distribution system, especially if it operates with continuous circulation. You will get a callback on this.

Figure 3
One relatively simple fix for this situation is to bring a portion of the distribution system down below the primary loop so that the closely spaced tees connecting the injection risers to the latter are at least 18 inches below the tees connecting the risers to the primary loop. This is shown in Figure 3.

Other important details for injection-mixing assemblies include:

  • Closely spaced tees at both ends of injection riser piping;
  • Providing purging provisions for the distribution system;
  • Providing a minimum of six diameters of straight pipe upstream and four pipe diameters downstream of the closely spaced tees;
  • Keeping electrical components away from potential water drips; and
  • Providing straight piping at all circulator inlets.


Figure 4

Harvey's Solution

My long-time associate Harvey Youker of Hytech Heating has developed a relatively simple detail for providing these injection mixing details in a good-looking piping assembly. I call it the Harvey Horseshoe. It's shown in Figure 4.

Harvey has used this detail on a number of multiload hydronic systems where two or more simultaneous water temperatures are needed. The approach is really pretty simple: Create a common primary loop and “populate it” with a separate mixing assembly for each water temperature required. If necessary, each distribution circuit can then be divided into two or more independently controlled zones using circulators, zone valves or valve actuators on manifolds. A call for heat from any of attached loads powers up the associated distribution circulator, injection controller, and allows the boiler and primary loop circulator to operate.

Harvey installs mixing assemblies that supply high temperature loads near the beginning of the primary loop and the low temperature subsystems near the end. In some systems, this allows the design temperature drop around the primary loop to be 20 or even 30 degrees F. A small 55-60 watt circulator can almost always serve as the primary loop circulator.

Figure 5
Figures 5 and 6 show how nicely this all looks in the mechanical room for a system supplying three mixed water temperatures and DHW. Be sure you check out the details such as:
  • A definite 18-inch thermal trap;
  • Closely spaced tees at top and bottom of injection risers;
  • The “drip loop” on the MC cable to prevent water from ever following the cable into the circulator junction boxes;
  • All circulator junction box openings pointing down for the same reason;
  • Approximately 12 diameters of straight pipe ahead of all circulators;
  • At least 6 diameters of straight pipe ahead of, and at least 4 diameters downstream of, closely spaced tees;
  • Electrical controls are not located where water can drip on them;
  • Easy accessibility to all serviceable hardware;
  • Well-supported piping; and
  • Neatly organized and well-protected wiring.


Figure 6
This approach does have some redundant hardware relative to designs that consolidate two or more mixing functions into a single controller. However, redundancy isn't all bad. If a given controller or its transformer fails, only that portion of the overall system is off-line until help arrives.

Harvey and I occasionally toss around ideas for further improving the horseshoe detail. Perhaps each mixing assembly could be made more compact with new primary/secondary fittings, or specialized purging valves. Maybe portions of the assembly could use bent tubing rather than 45-degree ells for the offsets. All of us should be looking for such potential improvements every time we design or fabricate a system. It's not only part of being a hydronic heating professional, it's fun! We welcome any suggestions that you might have.

Wishing you and your loved ones a blessed Christmas.

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Siegenthaler

John Siegenthaler, P.E., is a consulting engineer and principal of Appropriate Designs in Holland Patent, New York. In partnership with HeatSpring, he has developed several online courses that provide in-depth, design-level training in modern hydronics systems, air-to-water heat pumps and biomass boiler systems. Additional information and resources for hydronic system design are available on Siegenthaler’s website,  www.hydronicpros.com.

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • Worker using the Milwaukee Tool SWITCH PACK drain cleaner

    Pipeline profits: Drain cleaning, pipe inspection create opportunities

    Drain cleaning and inspection services offer lucrative...
    Green Plumbing and Mechanical
    By: Nicole Krawcke
  • Uponor employee, Arturo Moreno

    The reinvestment in American manufacturing and training

    Plumbing & Mechanical Chief Editor Nicole Krawcke and...
    Plumbing News
    By: Nicole Krawcke and Natalie Forster
  • March 2024 Women in Plumbing hero image of woman engineer overlayed by circle of hexagon shapes with numbers from 1 to 10

    Celebrating 10 Influential Women in the Plumbing Industry

    Celebrating Women's History Month and Women in...
    Plumbing News
    By: Nicole Krawcke
Subscribe For Free!
  • eNewsletters
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • eMagazine
  • Manage My Preferences

More Videos

Sponsored Content

Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the Plumbing & Mechanical audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of Plumbing & Mechanical or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

close
  • J.J. Keller CMV vehicles on road
    Sponsored byJ. J. Keller & Associates, Inc.

    The dash cam game-changer for small business safety

Popular Stories

The interior of a government building.

President Trump signs executive order promoting skilled trades and apprenticeships

Underfloor heating installation with drain sewer hole in bathroom close up on water floor heating.

Using hydronics to leverage time-of-use electrical rates

Watts Nexa mobile image

Behind the Wall: Where smart plumbing gets smarter

PMCE Home-X April 29 Free Webinar: From Legacy to Leadership: Preparing Your Home Services Business for the Next Generation

Events

November 13, 2024

Future Proofing MEP: Navigating the 2026 High Efficiency Water Heating Standards

Join our deep dive into DOE’s new standards so you can future-proof your MEP practice.

EARN: 0.1 ASPE CEU; 1 AIA LU/HSW; 0.1 IACET CEU*; 1 PDH

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Will business be up or down in 2025?

Do you anticipate business in 2025 to be up or down in comparison to 2024?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

The Water Came To A Stop

The Water Came To A Stop

See More Products

Download the FREE Water Conservation, Quality & Safety eBook: Plumbing Trends Increasing Safe Water Availability

Related Articles

  • John Siegenthaler Hydrolics Workshop

    Hydronic radiant ceiling cooling for smaller buildings.

    See More
  • John Siegenthaler Hydrolics Workshop

    The basics of radiant ceiling cooling

    See More
×

Keep your content unclogged with our newsletters!

Stay in the know on the latest plumbing & piping industry trends.

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Supply House Times
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing